Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at 11.32.09 AM.png

Pre-ordering for our 2018 Christmas menu is now open! Click the button below to reserve your Christmas pies, breads and treats.

NOTE: This order form closes at Friday, Dec. 21 and pickup for all Christmas orders is Monday, Dec. 24 (Christmas Eve) between 9am-12pm. Any questions, call us at 719.465.1856


Key Lime Pie - $28

In a sweet graham cracker crust made with organic browned butter, our traditional key lime pie filling toes the line elegantly between sweet and tart. We suggest whipping up a batch of lightly-sweetened whipped cream before your meal to serve atop this classic citrusy custard pie.

Cherry Cranberry Streusel Pie - $32

Hotchkiss organic cherries and fresh tart cranberries are the stars of our cherry cranberry streusel pie. Together with our whole spelt and butter crust and a generous brown sugar streusel topping, this festive pie will round out your Christmas table beautifully.

Cranberry Sage Bread - $8

Based on the Kansas Red medium whole wheat sourdough, this fine loaf includes fresh sage and dried cranberries. The perfect Christmas supper complement.

Kansas Red - $8

This medium whole wheat sourdough is a Nightingale best-seller. Simple, classic, delicious.

Seeded Loaf - $8

The beloved seeded loaf.

White Sourdough - $8

Our classic sourdough made with super high quality organic white flour: mild tang, great volume, nice and balanced flavor profile.

Christmas Cookie Box - $20

Our Christmas cookie box this year includes four varieties of charming holiday sweets: mini molasses spice cookies, mini Valrhona dark chocolate chunk cookies, salted honey peanut butter cookies and Dutch handkerchiefs (slightly sweet whole-spelt dough enveloping a meringue filling).

Breakfast Scone Box - $24

Our breakfast scone box includes two gingerbread maple scones, two cranberry white chocolate scones and two pear vanilla almond scones. A great addition to a Christmas brunch spread, or a simple solution for Christmas morning breakfast.

Nightingale Bread Gift Cards - Prices vary

How do you fit a whole loaf of bread in a Christmas stocking? With a Nightingale Bread gift card! We offer one loaf gift cards, $20 gift cards and a special offer of two $20 gift cards for just $35.

We'll plan to have extra of everything on pickup day, but using this form ensures we'll hold your order. That said, please only reserve if you'll certainly be here to pick up your order!

Note that the order form will close at 9pm on Friday, December 21, 2018.